Best Online Travel Guides

PCR travel tests need better policing, warns ex-watchdog boss Andrew Tyrie | Coronavirus

Poor service from suppliers of PCR travel tests is “an issue of national significance”, and regulators usually are not doing sufficient to police tons of of latest companies which have moved into the market, the previous competitors boss Andrew Tyrie has mentioned.

In an interview with the Guardian, Lord Tyrie, who was chairman of the Competition and Markets Authority till final 12 months, referred to as for a clear up of the listing of PCR check suppliers printed on the federal government web site, which many travellers seek the advice of earlier than shopping for a equipment.

Tyrie mentioned showing on the official listing has among the traits of a “licence” and it needs to be potential to implement minimal service requirements. “It’s not beyond the wit of man to ensure that a reasonable service is available.”

Andrew Tyrie pictured in 2015.Andrew Tyrie pictured in 2015. Photograph: Felix Clay


These measures ought to embrace companies taking legal responsibility for shopper prices when check outcomes are late and a staffed telephone line and electronic mail handle with a minimal response time, he says.

Customer critiques and efficiency scores, based mostly on information reminiscent of grievance charges or the proportion of tests processed on time – which corporations needs to be made to share – also needs to be seen on the official web site, Tyrie provides.

If shoppers got extra info to gauge the reliability of a service they may make their very own choices about whether or not to commerce high quality and reliability off in opposition to value. “That way the good firms can drive out the bad,” he mentioned.

The authorities web site, which lists testing corporations in value order, says it “does not endorse or recommend any specific test provider” and “you should do your own research”.


Tyrie, a former Conservative MP and chair of the Treasury choose committee, gained notoriety grilling prime ministers, Bank of England officers and banking chiefs after the 2008 monetary disaster. He resigned as chairman of the CMA final summer time.

Since leaving he has been essential of the watchdog’s efficiency. Problems within the testing market had been apparent because the spring and the CMA ought to have moved sooner, with warning letters or probably a check case, he argues.

The choice to disband the CMA’s newly created coronavirus taskforce was a mistake too, he suggests. The unit had been efficient within the early months of the pandemic when, for instance, it clamped down on suspected profiteering readily available sanitiser.

“The fact the taskforce was there and monitoring things itself almost certainly had a deterrent effect,” recommended Tyrie. “The CMA needs a small group of people dedicated to addressing this appalling detriment. It is threatening to become a massive rip off.”


The CMA has advised 25 PCR suppliers to scrub up their act or threat enforcement motion and has additionally begun formal investigations into Expert Medicals and Dante Labs. In the autumn it supplied its recommendation to Department of Health and Social Care on the way it might make the PCR market work better for shoppers.

At that point Andrea Coscelli, the CMA’s chief government, mentioned competitors alone was not sufficient to ship a wholesome market as a result of vital facets had been dictated by authorities coverage, so it wanted to take a extra “interventionist” method, backed up by monitoring and enforcement.

With the PCR travel check nonetheless a minefield for shoppers Tyrie mentioned the CMA had the “technical expertise to help the DHSC minimise the consumer detriment and needed to make every effort to put it at their disposal”.

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Back to top button