Sharks almost disappeared 19 million years ago and scientists don’t know why


A beforehand unknown extinction occasion brought about shark populations to break down 19 million years ago.


When Earth’s temperatures spiked and oxygen ranges within the ocean plummeted some 252 million years ago, most life on the planet was doomed. Some estimates counsel the extinction occasion, a mass extinction generally known as the Great Dying, killed off as much as 70% of all land species however marine animals felt the impression even better. As a lot as 96% of all species on this planet’s oceans perished.

But not sharks. The slender prowlers of the deep persevered. “They’re the ultimate survivors,” says Elizabeth Sibert, a paleobiologist and oceanographer at Yale University. The subsequent extinction occasion, on the finish of the Triassic interval, could not kill them off and neither may the asteroid that ended the reign of the dinosaurs some 66 million years ago. 


The longevity of sharks is known however they could have come a lot nearer to extinction than we as soon as believed, based on a brand new examine, published in the journal Science on Thursday. The analysis, led by Sibert, exhibits {that a} beforehand unknown extinction occasion pushed sharks to the brink 19 million years ago, leaving solely about one in 10 sharks within the open ocean alive. 

“Something happened that knocked out 90% of them overnight,” Sibert says. What that one thing was stays unsure, nevertheless it was undoubtedly devastating. The asteroid that worn out the dinosaurs resulted within the extinction of simply 30 to 35% of all shark species — this occasion was two to a few occasions worse. 

How did Sibert and her co-author Leah Rubin, a doctoral scholar on the State University of New York College of Environmental Science and Forestry, come upon this enigmatic marine die-off? It was a little bit of a shock, involving some deep-sea detective work and a mountain of microfossils.


Buried treasure

When a marine animal dies, its stays descend into the abyss, decomposing from entire creature to constituent elements. Tiny items of the fallen, just like the scales current on a shark (denticles) and tooth from fish rain down upon the ocean ground and, over time, pile up within the sediment. 

“The ocean floor is basically a graveyard for all of the life that’s living anywhere in the water column,” says Sibert. 

Each denticle or tooth is sort of a tiny gravestone. As they’re embedded into the sediment, they depart a fossilized document of life. These fossils are generally known as “icthyoliths.” And denticles don’t simply get subsumed by the sediment when a shark dies both. “They shed their denticles throughout their whole life,” notes Rubin. “That makes them a really abundant fossil.”

Extracting a cylindrical core of sediment permits scientists to research the forms of icthyoliths embedded inside — giving them a great proxy for what the ocean ecosystem appeared like throughout deep time. The deeper you dig, the additional again in time you may journey.


The sediment cores used within the examine come from two places within the Pacific Ocean, one northern and one southern website, and cowl a timescale of 40 million years. They had been gathered from about 3.5 miles under the floor by the JOIDES Resolution, a analysis vessel that may drill into the seafloor.


An unlimited array of denticles found from deep sea sediment.

Leah Rubin

It’s no simple feat to research the icthyoliths inside every core pattern, nonetheless. The fragments are extremely small, typically smaller than half the width of a human hair and they arrive in a dizzying, stunning array of shapes and sizes.  

Sibert would sift by means of dry sediment beneath a microscope and separate out the denticles for this venture, a process she’s change into good at after selecting almost 200,000 out of the ocean filth in her research. After isolating the denticles, it was Rubin’s job to assist identify and describe their traits, to distinguish them from one another. 

The denticles glisten beneath gentle, radiating blues, muted greens and oranges, and are given names as descriptive as “Two Big Lobes” (for a denticle containing, nicely, two huge lobes) to the extra fanciful “Whale Blow” and “Wrinkly Kite.” You can see a number of them within the picture to the suitable. 

The denticles inform the story. There are almost 1,300 within the examine, with 85 distinct geometric shapes. The majority of them described by Sibert and Rubin are from previous to 19 million years ago, with only some dozen discovered within the sediment cores after that point. The denticles disappear… so what occurred to the sharks?

Extinction X

The denticles present a decline in shark numbers and variety round 19 million years ago however there is no apparent trigger behind the occasion. “It really, truly is a mystery right now, we don’t know what happened,” says Sibert.

The key to fixing the thriller can be understanding the time period the sharks appeared to almost disappear. It’s generally known as the “Miocene” and Sibert describes it as a “transition period” for the Earth. Around 15 million years earlier than the sharks mysterious extinction occasion, Earth was slowly changing into an “ice house” planet and a everlasting ice sheet was rising over Antarctica. Even so, the planet was nonetheless a lot hotter than it’s at this time.

“If I showed you a map,” Sibert says “you’d kind of recognize everything but overall it would look just a little bit off.”

The oceans of the time weren’t all that totally different to the oceans of at this time, although you would not discover issues like tuna, swordfish or seabirds. Whales and dolphins had been but to evolve, too. Unfortunately, there’s not a variety of prime quality information of this time within the Earth’s historical past — scientists simply have not spent a variety of time taking a look at it and it additionally appears to be poorly preserved within the deep sea sediments collected by drilling applications. 

So there’s not a variety of proof to catch the shark killer, so to talk, however there are avenues to analyze. Discovering Extinction X on this unremarkable interval of the Earth’s historical past is simply the tip of the iceberg. 

“This paper definitely offers a ton more questions than it offers answers,” says Rubin. 

Could there have been an environmental driving pressure that brought about the shark’s decline? It’s onerous to say. Carbon and oxygen ranges don’t present any uncommon aberrations however scientists may use much more knowledge round this time level. Did this happen throughout all of the world’s oceans and in different marine life? Sibert thinks this was a worldwide occasion, however we’d like extra information.

And what about different our bodies of water? Lakes and coastal sediments would possibly present a unique phenomenon once more. How did land animals fare throughout this time? Are there different chemical proxies that may inform us about what the atmosphere was like for them? 

Sibert even suggests a pathogen, like a virus, could possibly be liable for the reducing numbers, although it will be a lot more durable to point out this was the case. 

For Sibert, the extinction stands out. Given that sharks have been round for 400 million years or extra, surviving a number of mass extinction occasions, she believes one thing actually important will need to have occurred and the sharks could also be a doorway to understanding larger modifications to the Earth system throughout the early Miocene. “There’s more data waiting to be found,” says Rubin.

One of the most important regarding points is that populations by no means actually had an opportunity to bounce again from this occasion. Finding this historical past within the fossil document highlights the fragility or the marine atmosphere and how troublesome it may be for species to get better when they’re pushed to the brink of extinction.

“The biology is trying to tell us something, and I think we need to listen,” says Sibert.

Show More

Related Articles

Back to top button